Federal Judge Chutkan Temporarily Blocks Trump's Triumphal Arch Hours After the Planning Commission Approved It 8 to 4, Washington Examiner Reports
Judge Tanya Chutkan issued a 14-day restraining order late Thursday that stops the administration from breaking ground on the 250-foot arch. The White House called it the work of an 'activist district court' and says it expects to be vindicated. A compliance report is due Monday.
A federal judge has put President Donald Trump's planned triumphal arch on hold for now, the Washington Examiner reports. The order came only hours after a federal planning commission approved the project.
The ruling. U.S. District Judge Tanya Chutkan, an Obama appointee, issued a 14-day temporary restraining order late Thursday. It bars the administration from breaking ground on the proposed 250-foot monument. She also ordered the administration to file a compliance report on Monday.
The vote it follows. The National Capital Planning Commission approved the arch 8 to 4 after more than nine hours of public testimony, much of it against the project. The Examiner says the vote split between federal delegates, who backed it, and local representatives, who opposed it. We covered that vote earlier in our report on the 8 to 4 approval.
The size. The Examiner says the main structure is about 160 feet tall and reaches 250 feet once a gold-winged figure and two eagles on top are counted. It is planned between the Lincoln Memorial and Arlington National Cemetery.
Why the judge sided with the plaintiffs. Virginia and the District of Columbia, which sued last month, argued construction would disrupt traffic, emergency response and local government operations. The Examiner says Chutkan found they faced significant costs and possible harm if work started before the courts settled the legal questions. Critics also argue the arch needs approval from Congress and would disrupt historic views. Administration officials say a 1925 law gave them authority for a memorial at the site. The Examiner says Chutkan questioned whether a century-old statute could cover a monument of this size without further action from Congress.
The White House response. Spokesman Davis Ingle thanked the planning commission for approving what he called the president's "historic vision." He said "an activist district court thereafter blocked the construction of the project," and added, "We are confident we will be fully vindicated as this litigation proceeds."
More lawsuits. The Examiner says other suits are pending. Arlington County, which owns the land around the site, sued Interior Secretary Doug Burgum and National Park Service Director Jessica Bowron earlier this month. It says officials rushed the approval to avoid full review.
Why it matters here. The commission's vote looked like the last big hurdle. It was not. The order is temporary, and the court has not ruled on whether the arch is lawful. The next date to watch is Monday's compliance report, then the end of the 14 days.
What we could not check. We did not read the order. The description of it, the vote split and the legal arguments come from the Examiner. We have not seen the 1925 law's text. The Examiner's report names the arch's location as near Arlington National Cemetery, while earlier coverage we ran described a site near the Memorial Bridge. We did not resolve that difference.