RightNewsRight NowThe headlines that matter. Credited. Unspun.
RightNewsRight Now
Politics

Fox News: White House Counsel Warns Incoming Oversight Chair Robert Garcia That Abusive Subpoenas Could Cross Into Criminality, and Legal Experts Doubt Prosecutors Could Make It Stick

Fox says legal voices on the right and left agree the White House can fight subpoenas in court but would struggle to bring charges over oversight itself. Garcia says Congress needs no permission from the White House.

Illustration: RightNewsRightNow.

The White House has put the incoming House Democratic majority on notice about investigations, Fox News reports. We read Fox's full text.

The letter. Fox says White House counsel William Scharf wrote on Nov. 9 to Rep. Robert Garcia, D-Calif., the top Democrat on the House Oversight Committee and its likely chairman next year. The letter says Congress's subpoena power has constitutional limits and that it exists for oversight, not for harassment. It warns that threats against executive branch officials meant to scare them out of public service, or subpoenas meant only to instill fear, "may cross the line into blatant criminality." Fox says the letter came a week after Democrats posted calls for subpoenas and impeachment trials.

Garcia's answer. He says Congress's authority comes from Article I of the Constitution "not from the permission of the White House," and that the letter suggests the president has something to hide. He called the threats baseless and said a "weaponized DOJ" will not deter the committee.

The experts. Fox interviewed lawyers across the spectrum. Ilya Shapiro of the Manhattan Institute said the administration can assert privilege and challenge subpoenas in court, but a criminal case is a "very different animal" with a higher bar. Hans von Spakovsky of Advancing American Freedom agreed that investigations meant only to harass can be unconstitutional, and said he was unsure which criminal law would apply. Will Chamberlain of the Article III Project said oversight itself is not a crime, but a separate conspiracy to intimidate federal officers, shown by threats or press releases, could be. Molly Nixon of the Cato Institute doubted the letter's leap to criminality. Devon Ombres of the Center for American Progress said he expects the White House and Justice Department to fight subpoenas in court.

What we could not check. We did not read the letter or Garcia's full statement. Fox does not say that any subpoena has been issued. The legal opinions are the experts' own, as Fox quotes them.

More stories