Washington Ranchers Fined $267,540 Over Stock Ponds Say Losing Their Fight for a Jury Trial Would Be an 'Existential Threat,' Fox News Reports
Fox News says a Grant County family was fined by Washington's Department of Ecology over ponds it calls wetlands damage and the family calls livestock water. They want a jury, and their lawyers say the case could reach the Supreme Court. The state disputes their account.
A Washington cattle family says a state fine has turned into a fight over whether regulators can punish landowners without a jury, Fox News reports.
The fine. Wade and Teresa King own King Ranch in Grant and Douglas counties. Fox says the state Department of Ecology fined them $267,540 in 2023 for allegedly damaging regulated wetlands by digging ponds for their cattle. The Kings say the areas are long-standing stockwater ponds, not wetlands. The Kings' attorneys estimate that complying with the department's restoration orders could cost more than $3.7 million.
The jury question. The department's process sent the Kings to the Pollution Control Hearings Board, an administrative panel that does not hold jury trials. In March the Kings sued in Grant County Superior Court, arguing the board should not decide the case. A judge later dismissed that suit and said they had to finish the administrative process first. The Kings appealed, and a Washington Court of Appeals commissioner paused the board's proceedings in September while the court considers whether they are entitled to a jury. The board declined to comment because the case is pending.
The family's case. Wade King told Fox the board is part of the executive branch and "almost always" sides with agencies. He said Gov. Bob Ferguson, who was attorney general when the dispute began, now shares appointment power over the board with the state Senate. Teresa King said the Kings are "defending every rancher in the state of Washington's exempt livestock water rights."
The legal stakes. Oliver Dunford, a senior attorney at Pacific Legal Foundation representing the Kings, said they are ready to petition the U.S. Supreme Court if they lose in Washington. He said the question would be whether the Seventh Amendment's jury right applies against the states, and he told Fox a win could reach well beyond Washington.
The state's side. The department told Fox its investigation found no evidence the areas were ever stockwater ponds. It says the Kings damaged 23 naturally occurring wetlands in Grant County, about 6.37 acres, using satellite imagery, aerial photos dating to 1949 and other records. It says it tried repeatedly to resolve the matter and the Kings refused to cooperate. It also says it ordered restoration of 11 more areas in Douglas County last year, for a total of 34, most of them on state land.
Why it matters here. Property owners and farm groups who see regulators as judge and jury will watch whether the courts require a jury in cases like this. The outcome would also affect how states enforce wetlands rules.
What we could not check. We read Fox's report, not the court filings or the department's orders. The wetlands finding, the acreage and the cost estimate are each side's own claims, and we cannot say who is right.