Trump, Xi and Putin End First Three-Way Talks With No Major Breakthroughs, and a Joint Statement That Takes Aim at the International Criminal Court, AP Reports
AP says the three leaders agreed on points including United Nations reforms and getting more fuel to market, but their short statement did not mention Ukraine or Iran. It did warn the ICC against abusing its jurisdiction.
This is breaking news and a follow-up to our earlier reports on the Shenzhen meetings. We read the Associated Press report on how the talks ended, and Fox News coverage of the same session. Quotes and judgments are AP's or Fox's, or those of the people they name.
How it ended. AP says the three leaders sat around a table together for the first time on Thursday to talk about reducing nuclear risks and resolving conflicts, and applauded the step as historic, though they did not agree to any major breakthroughs. They finished at a villa in the southern Chinese city of Shenzhen by agreeing on points including United Nations reforms and a vow to get more fuel to market. AP says it remains to be seen whether the gathering marks a pivot in world history or becomes a quickly forgotten photo op.
What was and was not said. AP says the leaders gave brief remarks at the start, took no questions afterward, and released a short statement that did not mention the wars in Ukraine or Iran. Trump said he raised both with the other two leaders in separate one-on-one meetings earlier in the day. "We are really making history," Trump said. He added that the United States, Russia and China are "uniquely positioned to discuss how to reduce the number of nuclear weapons on Earth and also to lessen the risk of those weapons being used." Xi called the talks positive, constructive and fruitful. Putin called them open and candid and the format "useful and substantive." Fox quotes Trump on the difficulty: "It's a very hard thing to do, because once you have the nuclear weapons, it's very hard to not have them."
The ICC line. AP says the joint statement took aim at the International Criminal Court, saying state officials should enjoy immunity from its prosecutions and warning that it should not abuse its jurisdiction. AP notes that Putin is wanted by the court and that the Trump administration has imposed sanctions on ICC officials and the institution itself. Fox reports Trump said ahead of the meeting that the leaders would discuss protecting national sovereignty from international organizations, and singled out the ICC.
Arms control. AP says the last nuclear arms pact between Russia and the United States, New START, expired in February, and Trump has said he wants "a new, improved and modernized" deal that includes China. AP says China has less motivation to accept limits because its arsenal of more than 600 warheads is far smaller than the more than 5,000 believed to be in each of the American and Russian stockpiles. Daryl Kimball of the Arms Control Association told AP the meeting could at best start a process that leads to sustained talks, adding, "We need more than diplomatic theater and photo opportunities between Xi, Putin and Trump."
Iran and trade. AP says Trump and Xi share an interest in oil shipping through the Strait of Hormuz, and that Trump suggested he would push Xi to buy more American farm goods. Xinhua reported that Xi raised Taiwan with Trump. Fox quotes Trump as saying both countries want to keep energy flowing through the strait and to make sure Iran cannot have a nuclear weapon.
Friction. AP reports Chinese officials blocked a Bloomberg reporter from the three-way meeting after she asked a question at the earlier Trump-Xi session. Fox says the reporter, Annmarie Hordern, had asked whether Jensen Huang had been "disloyal to the United States," that the White House pushed for her to be admitted, and that Beijing refused. Fox says China also warned the press pool that shouted questions are "extremely rude." AP adds that Chinese television showed a video of Trump appearing drowsy, while the White House posted a clip of him helping Xi up an escalator.
What comes next. AP says Trump and Xi have one more meeting planned this year, at the G20 summit in Florida in December. AP also notes that Trump is negotiating with China and Russia without Ukraine, or allies such as Germany, France, Britain, Japan and South Korea.
What we could not check. We read news reports, not the text of the joint statement. We have not seen any readout from the three governments beyond what AP and Fox quote.
Sources: The Associated Press and Fox News. Read the original reports: https://apnews.com/article/trump-xi-putin-nuclear-ukraine-iran-a04dc76ed8e786b087e2c1ea9598783a and https://www.foxnews.com/politics/trumps-historic-summit-xi-putin-marks-diplomatic-milestone-breakthroughs-remain-elusive and https://www.foxnews.com/politics/china-blocks-bloomberg-reporter-trump-putin-xi-meeting-question-trump