The Administration Is Finalizing a Rule to Pay Doctors Who Treat Vaccine 'Injury,' the Guardian Reports; HHS Rejects Claims of Personal Gain
The Guardian says the rule would reimburse diagnosing, treating and counseling vaccine side effects. Experts it quotes see an effort to cast doubt on vaccines. HHS 'categorically' rejects the claims.
We read the Guardian's Sunday report in full. It is a critical account, and much of it rests on outside experts' views, so we label whose claim is whose.
What is planned. The Guardian reports that the Trump administration is finalizing a rule to reimburse doctors who diagnose, treat and counsel patients about side effects from vaccines. Health Secretary Robert F. Kennedy Jr. has also announced a vaccine "injury" research center at the National Institutes of Health and has sought to reshape the Vaccine Injury Compensation Program, the Guardian says. We did not find the rule text, and the Guardian does not give a publication date for it.
The critics. Experts quoted by the paper say the changes are meant to undermine trust in vaccines and build an evidence base on their purported risks. Dorit Reiss, a law professor at UC Law San Francisco, called Kennedy "a real ideologue" and warned that paying doctors to report side effects to the federal VAERS database risks "the wrong incentives." Peter Hotez of Baylor College of Medicine said VAERS "was never meant to show cause and effect." He said it is good at flagging rare signals, such as myocarditis after early mRNA Covid vaccines, but cannot prove a link. Reiss also said the changes could be used by groups such as Children's Health Defense to lend legitimacy to their work.
The money claims. The Guardian says Kennedy disclosed $2.5 million in income from referrals for vaccine-related lawsuits before his January 2025 confirmation hearing, and that a Merck HPV vaccine litigation he was involved in settled for more than $50 million in June 2026. It says Kennedy said his son would receive the money, expected to be 10% of the total, and it is unclear whether he did. It also cites reports of $4 million in book advances from his publisher over the past year and some $250,000 in gifts of flights and yacht trips from a former campaign donor, who is under Senate investigation. These are the Guardian's reports, and we did not verify them.
The compensation system. Reiss and Hotez argue that shifting vaccines to "shared clinical decision-making," which Kennedy's former lawyer Aaron Siri has advocated, could take them out of the 1986 compensation program and open them to lawsuits. Siri did not answer the Guardian's question on profiting from litigation. He said that "if vaccines are as 'safe' as touted by the government, then there should be no need for immunity to liability and, likewise, there should be very few, if any, successful cases."
HHS's answer. HHS spokesperson Emily Hilliard said the department "categorically reject claims that Secretary Kennedy is pursuing personal gain or seeking to dismantle American medicine."
What we could not check. We did not see the rule, the NIH announcement or the financial records cited. The paper links the plan to motives, and HHS denies them.