Susan Smith Is Denied Parole More Than 30 Years After Drowning Her Two Sons, and Their Father Tells the Board It Would Be 'a Huge Injustice,' Fox News Reports
Fox says a seven-member South Carolina parole board ruled against Smith on Thursday morning. Her lawyer read a statement saying she had lost touch with reality in 1994, and her ex-husband urged the board to keep her in prison.
This is breaking news. We read the Fox News report published Thursday morning and updated at 12:43 p.m. Eastern. Quotes and details are as Fox reports them. This story involves the deaths of children.
The decision. Fox says Susan Smith was denied parole on Thursday by a seven-member parole board in Columbia, South Carolina, more than three decades after she drowned her two young sons. She appeared by video, according to Fox's photo caption. Fox says she was convicted of two counts of murder in 1995 and sentenced to life, and that state law at the time let her be considered for parole after 30 years. Fox says this was not her first try: she was denied at her first hearing in November 2024. We did not find the board's written decision, and Fox does not say how the board voted.
The case. Fox says Smith strapped her sons, 3-year-old Michael and 14-month-old Alexander, into her car and let it roll into a lake on Oct. 25, 1994. Prosecutors argued she did it to win back a former lover who did not want children. Fox says she first gave police a false account that a Black man had carjacked her and taken the boys, and appeared on national television with her then-husband pleading for their return.
What Smith said. Fox quotes her telling the board, "I know I promised them an unbearable pain. And I know that David didn't get to see Michael and Alex grow up," and, "I'm not the same person I was 32 years ago. I have changed." Fox says she said she wants to live her life "to honor the memory of Michael and Alex." Her attorney, Tommy Thomas, read a statement in which she said she had "lost touch with reality" when the boys died and believed Jesus could care for them better than she could. Those are her words and her lawyer's account, not findings.
What the father said. Fox says Smith's ex-husband, David Smith, urged the board to keep her in prison. He said, "She did that deliberately. It wasn't an accident. It wasn't a bad mistake," and added, "I know in my heart, granting parole would be a huge injustice to Michael and Alex."
The prosecutor. Fox says Tommy Pope, who tried the case and is now speaker pro tempore of the South Carolina House, told Fox News Digital that if Smith were freed she would use social media and "love the attention," and that it would be "in David's face every day." He said the jury believed it was giving her a real life sentence, and that her remorse "is for her circumstances, not for those boys." Those are his opinions.
What we could not check. We read Fox's report, not the hearing itself or the board's order. Fox does not say when Smith may be eligible to apply again.