RightNewsRight NowThe headlines that matter. Credited. Unspun.
RightNewsRight Now
Border & Security

Justices of Both Camps Press the Lawyer for Sun Valley Orchards in a Case on Fining Employers Under the H-2A Farmworker Program, Daily Caller Reports

The Daily Caller says Kagan, Kavanaugh, Barrett and Sotomayor challenged the company's argument that a $550,000 Labor Department penalty belonged in a court, not an agency. No ruling yet.

Illustration: RightNewsRightNow.

The Supreme Court heard arguments Tuesday in a case about whether the Labor Department can fine employers under the H-2A foreign farmworker program, the Daily Caller reports. We read the Caller's full text. The court has not ruled.

The case. In Department of Labor v. Sun Valley Orchards, the Caller says the department fined the company $550,000 in 2015 after an inspection found worker living conditions broke H-2A rules meant to protect American workers from being undercut by cheaper foreign labor. The company argues those civil penalties are a contract matter that belongs in a court under Article Three of the Constitution, not in the department's internal process.

The pressure on the company's lawyer. The Caller says Rob Johnson faced hard questions from liberal and conservative justices alike. Justice Elena Kagan told him his argument rests on the idea that H-2A "is not an immigration program," but "it is an immigration program," about when to admit foreign workers given the concern they "will undercut the economic status of domestic workers." Justice Brett Kavanaugh pressed him on whether he accepted an immigration exception and said "Can I get an answer?" Justice Amy Coney Barrett told him to answer "yes" or "no." Johnson said "Yes, but I don't think the Court should go that far in this case."

The precedent. The department cited Oceanic Steam Navigation Co. v. Stranahan, which let the executive branch fine shipping companies over immigration violations. Johnson argued Oceanic was an admissions case and his client's workers were already in the country. Kagan answered that this too is an admissions case, because employers certify conditions to bring in workers and the fines follow broken promises. Justice Sonia Sotomayor said agencies have long had processes to punish employers who "lied to bring people in."

What we could not check. We did not hear the arguments. Justices' questions do not predict a ruling, and the Caller's text does not give the company's or the department's full position beyond what is quoted here.

More stories