Sotomayor Says She Hopes the Supreme Court Overturns Its Presidential Immunity Ruling in Her Lifetime, Fox News Reports
Fox News says the liberal justice named the 2024 immunity decision at a Mount Vernon civics event. She joked the court should take back 'crazy things,' then added 'maybe not.'
Justice Sonia Sotomayor said over the weekend that she hopes the court's presidential immunity decision will someday be reversed, Fox News reports.
The event. Fox says she spoke at a civics education event at George Washington's Mount Vernon estate. It says she spent most of the hourlong program on civics education and the state of American democracy.
What she said. In Fox's account, Sotomayor said, "I dissent a lot. I'm hoping that the court will take back some of the crazy things that it's done. I'm only joking, maybe not." She then said she has spoken openly about opinions she hopes will be overturned "in my lifetime," and named the immunity case. She also said some norms "may have lost forever" but that she does not think the country will "fail as a democracy."
The ruling. Fox says Trump v. United States held that former presidents have absolute immunity for actions within their core constitutional powers and at least presumptive immunity for other official acts, with no immunity for unofficial conduct. Fox says Sotomayor wrote in her 2024 dissent that the majority had made the president a "king above the law."
The politics. Fox ties the remarks to the midterms, noting Democrats now control the Senate. It points out that Justices Samuel Alito and Clarence Thomas are in their late 70s, which raises questions about retirements and whether a Democratic Senate would complicate Trump's efforts to replace them. Fox says Sotomayor also told the audience that voter turnout showed "there's no excuse for not voting."
What we could not check. We read Fox's full report. We did not see the event, and the quotes are as Fox relays them. Fox's text includes no reply from the court's conservatives or from Trump's allies.