New York Post Editorial: Democrats' Ideas to 'Fix' Social Security Would Make the Trust Fund Problem Worse
The New York Post editorial board says the Social Security trust funds empty in six years and trigger a 22% automatic cut. It argues Democratic plans to raise taxes or boost payouts do not close the gap. It is an editorial, not a news report.
The New York Post's editorial board uses the Democratic win in Congress to warn about Social Security's finances.
The numbers. The Post says the program is on track to go bust in 2032, when the trust fund runs out and payments shrink automatically by about 22%. It says the Old-Age, Survivors, and Disability Insurance trust funds paid out $160 billion more than they took in last year, and that gap is on pace to reach $400 billion by 2033 as the population ages and the ratio of workers to beneficiaries falls. Reserves now cover the shortfall.
The Democratic ideas it criticizes. The Post lists plans to raise the payroll tax cap, now $184,500 and rising to $192,300 next year, or remove it. It says that would reach far more than millionaires. It also lists a new tax on incomes above $250,000 and a levy on net investment income. On the benefit side, it says some Democrats want bigger payments and more generous cost-of-living increases.
Its argument. The Post says tax hikes would hurt economic growth and raise less than Democrats project. It grants some tax increases might narrow the yearly deficit, but says none would close it, only pushing the date back a few years. It says larger benefits would deepen the hole. It also says no one, including Republicans, wants to cut payments or raise the retirement age, so the 22% cut may happen.
The wider warning. The editorial says Medicaid, Medicare and Obamacare are in worse shape, and that a Democratic Congress would struggle to shore them up without heavy borrowing that it says would bring back "Biden-era hyperinflation." It ends by saying Democrats will have to work with Republicans on bipartisan solutions.
What we could not check. This is an editorial. We did not verify the trust fund projections or the tax cap figures against the Social Security trustees' report. The Post does not name which Democrats back which plans, and we did not check that.