RightNewsRight NowThe headlines that matter. Credited. Unspun.
RightNewsRight Now
Politics

A Federal Appeals Court Weighs Whether to Step In on Trump's Hush Money Conviction, Questioning His Lawyer for More Than an Hour With No Immediate Decision, AP Reports

Two of the three judges pressed Trump's lawyer on how a move to federal court would work. It is the second court hearing in 11 days as Trump pursues two appeals at once.

Illustration: RightNewsRightNow.

We read the Associated Press's Monday report on the hearing. We did not attend. Quotes are the AP's.

What happened. A three-judge panel of the 2nd U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals spent more than an hour Monday questioning Trump's lawyer and a Manhattan prosecutor about Trump's latest attempt to move his hush money case from state court to federal court. AP says there was no immediate decision. It was the second time the sides had been in court in 11 days. Trump is pursuing two tracks at once: this federal effort and a regular appeal through New York's state courts, where the mid-level Appellate Division heard arguments Nov. 5 and has not ruled.

The background. Trump was convicted in May 2024 on 34 felony counts of falsifying business records to hide a $130,000 payment to Stormy Daniels. AP says he denies wrongdoing and was given no punishment. His goal in federal court is to seek dismissal on presidential immunity grounds.

The request. Trump's lawyer, Robert Giuffra Jr., asked the judges to issue an order as soon as possible, even before writing a full decision, to take control of the case and stop the Appellate Division's deliberations. He said that without federal intervention Trump "will likely have to wait years" for state appeals to finish before he can go to the U.S. Supreme Court. He argued that prosecutors used the kind of official-acts evidence the Supreme Court later barred in its July 2024 immunity ruling, including testimony about Oval Office conversations, workflow and social media posts. He also said the prosecution's description of the payment as an illegal campaign contribution under federal election law belongs in federal court.

The judges' questions. Judge John M. Walker Jr. asked, "How does that work?" and wondered whether everyone would have to refile briefs in the Appellate Division. Giuffra said the case would first go to a federal district judge who would adopt the state verdict, and that the briefs would stay the same "albeit with different covers." Chief Judge Raymond J. Lohier Jr. said: "You're asking us to embrace an entire procedural mechanism that I don't see anywhere authorized by Congress." Giuffra replied, "We think it is authorized," calling the provision for post-verdict transfers "a safety valve that's intended to protect against exactly the gamesmanship that's gone on here."

The other side. Steven Wu, chief of the appeals division at the Manhattan District Attorney's Office, urged the panel to uphold the lower court's ruling and keep the case in state court. He said that even if Trump won, the state appeals court would still be free to rule.

How it got here. AP says U.S. District Judge Alvin K. Hellerstein, who died last month at 92, rejected Trump's transfer bid three times. In August he wrote that "paying hush money to an adult film star or engaging in a cover-up of an embarrassment are not subsumed in presidential immunity." The 2nd Circuit earlier ordered him to reconsider after his second denial, without saying how he should rule.

What we could not check. We did not hear the arguments. AP does not say when the panel might rule, and we do not predict it. AP names Walker and Lohier as questioning; it does not name the third judge in the text we read.

More stories