# Washington Times: Federal Appeals Court Rules Against Trump Administration in Fight Over New York Truck Licenses for Migrants With Temporary Status

The 2nd Circuit says the old federal rules had no requirement that a license expire with a work permit, and the administration conceded that. The Transportation Department had docked New York $73.5 million. A newer rule remains in effect.

- Section: [Border & Security](https://rightnewsrightnow.com/border-security/)
- Published: 2026-11-14
- By: RightNewsRightNow Staff
- Canonical page: https://rightnewsrightnow.com/articles/second-circuit-new-york-commercial-drivers-licenses-non-domiciled-migrants-work-permits-fmcsa-73-million-judge-nathan-washington-times/

New York has won a round in a fight over who gets a commercial driver's license, the Washington Times reports. We read the Times' full text.

The ruling. The Times says the 2nd U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals found New York was on solid legal footing when it issued commercial licenses to migrants with temporary status that ran longer than their federal work permits. Judge Alison J. Nathan, a Biden appointee, wrote that the Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration "concedes that the plain text of the regulations does not contain an expiration-matching requirement." Judges Sara Merriam, another Biden pick, and Matthew Schwartz, a Trump appointee, joined her. The ruling overturned the Transportation Department's decision.

The dispute. Trump officials called it "common sense" for a license not to outlast a work permit. The Times says New York allowed licenses valid for five years for new drivers and up to eight for renewals, and let so-called non-domiciled drivers, migrants allowed to stay but without full legal status, obtain them. Federal investigators reviewed 200 such licenses from New York and found 101 with dates beyond the holder's work permit. The department said it would hold back $73.5 million from New York until the licenses were revoked, and the state sued.

What happens next. The Times says the agency has since rewritten the regulation to remove the conflict. That version has been challenged in court but stays in effect while the case plays out. It notes non-domiciled licenses have been a focus of the administration, which says they are dangerous, and that the department shut down 110 big-rig driving schools over the summer over concerns about drivers' English.

What we could not check. The court's reasoning is as the Times describes it. We did not read the opinion, and the report does not say whether the administration will appeal or whether the $73.5 million is released.

## Source

Original reporting: [Washington Times](https://www.washingtontimes.com/news/2026/nov/13/new-york-triumphs-case-issuing-truck-drivers-licenses-illegal/)
