Scott Jennings Moves to Dismiss Hasan Piker's $72.5 Million Defamation Suit, Daily Wire Reports
The Daily Wire says Jennings filed a motion Tuesday arguing the NRSC clip he cited shows words Piker said and that Piker cannot prove actual malice. Piker says the clip was cut and his remarks were sarcastic.
Conservative commentator Scott Jennings has asked a court to throw out streamer Hasan Piker's defamation lawsuit, the Daily Wire reports. The outlet says it was first to report the filing. The case has not been decided.
The suit. The Daily Wire says Piker, a close ally of Michigan Senator-elect Abdul El-Sayed, sued last week over an August episode of Jennings' radio show. Jennings said Piker was "out there calling for Black voters to be lynched." Piker is seeking at least $27.5 million in compensatory damages and $45 million in punitive damages. Our earlier coverage reported the suit when it was filed.
Piker's side. According to his complaint, as the Daily Wire describes it, Jennings relied on a 42-second clip shared on X by the National Republican Senatorial Committee that takes Piker's remarks from an October 2024 livestream out of context. Piker says the remarks were sarcastic, that the clip leaves out the words "he said" and his laughter, and that Jennings added an on-screen caption Piker's lawyers say he never used.
Jennings' side. In the motion, the Daily Wire says, Jennings' attorney Benjamin Chew writes that Jennings "did not create, edit, or manipulate" the video and had no reason to doubt it. The motion argues the clip shows statements Piker really made, that "the accurate quoting of another's statement cannot defame the speaker," and that the dispute is over what Piker meant, which is "not sufficiently verifiable to be actionable." It also cites other past statements by Piker to argue Jennings had no reason to assume he was joking.
The legal test. The Daily Wire notes that as a public figure, Piker must show "actual malice," meaning Jennings knew his statements were false or recklessly disregarded the truth. The motion says Piker's allegations fall short of that as a matter of law.
What we could not check. We read the Daily Wire's full report. We did not read the complaint, the motion, or the video. The report does not include a response from Piker or his lawyers to the motion, and the Daily Wire's account of the clip is its own.