# Fox News Column: Sanctuary States Have a DMV Problem, and Trump Can Demand Answers, Paul Mauro Says

Fox News contributor Paul Mauro uses a fatal Connecticut crash to argue the administration should subpoena state DMV records to find illegal immigrants with licenses. His column, not a news report.

- Section: [Border & Security](https://rightnewsrightnow.com/border-security/)
- Published: 2026-11-10
- By: RightNewsRightNow Staff
- Canonical page: https://rightnewsrightnow.com/articles/paul-mauro-column-sanctuary-states-dmv-problem-ryan-oshea-connecticut-crash-carmona-lopez-cdl-task-force-kaplan-subpoena-fox-news/

This is a column by Paul Mauro in Fox News Opinion. The views and claims are his, and we summarize them here.

The case he opens with. Mauro writes about Ryan O'Shea, a 21-year-old University of New Haven hockey captain who studied criminal justice. He was killed Oct. 16 when a pickup driving the wrong way on Connecticut's Interstate 91 hit his car head-on. Mauro says police identified the driver as Guillermo Carmona-Lopez, a Mexican national whom DHS says had already been removed from the country twice. Mauro says the story got little mainstream coverage.

The pattern. He lists other crashes: an Uzbek national who held an Ohio commercial license and is accused in the July death of 21-year-old Toby Forsythe, and an Indian national DHS calls illegal, accused in the Sept. 2 death of 50-year-old Brenda Watson. He says Transportation Secretary Sean Duffy's audit found over half of New York's commercial licenses went to illegal drivers and 25% of California's were unlawfully issued. He says Duffy withheld $73 million from New York, which is suing, and that a federal task force began with more than 1,000 leads and has inspected more than 200 driving schools in 23 states.

His argument. Mauro says the crash that killed O'Shea involved a driver without a commercial license, so a task force limited to those licenses is too narrow. He wants the administration to go after state DMV records. He points to a Nov. 6 ruling by Judge Lewis Kaplan ordering New York City to comply with an ICE subpoena about migrants with serious criminal histories at a Bronx shelter, and says similar court-enforced subpoenas could identify criminal aliens who hold licenses. He says at least 17 states plus Washington, D.C., let people here illegally get licenses and also automatically register license holders to vote. He also says the approach would open "another front" that avoids highly visible ICE sweeps.

The close. Mauro quotes New York Gov. Kathy Hochul saying "75% of Americans will be governed by DEM Govs." He says the other 25% should show what makes them different by cooperating with federal officials to keep illegal drivers off the roads and to go after the criminal networks behind the trafficking.

What we could not check. We read the full column. We did not verify the crash details, the audit numbers, the voter registration claim or the court ruling, and the column does not include a response from the states it criticizes. These are Mauro's views, not ours.

## Source

Original reporting: [Fox News (opinion)](https://www.foxnews.com/opinion/paul-mauro-sanctuary-states-dmv-problem-trump-can-demand-answers)
