# Opinion: Simon Hankinson Says France Is Putting Free Speech on Trial by Pursuing Novelist Michel Houellebecq, Daily Wire Reports

Writing in the Daily Wire, a Heritage Foundation fellow argues that France, Britain and Germany lack a First Amendment and that America should hold fast to its own. This is his opinion.

- Section: [Opinion](https://rightnewsrightnow.com/opinion/)
- Published: 2026-11-15
- By: RightNewsRightNow Staff
- Canonical page: https://rightnewsrightnow.com/articles/opinion-simon-hankinson-france-michel-houellebecq-free-speech-islam-investigation-great-replacement-heritage-daily-wire/

This is an opinion column by Simon Hankinson, a senior research fellow at The Heritage Foundation's Border Security and Immigration Center. The views and labels are his, and we summarize them here. We read the full piece in the Daily Wire.

The case. Hankinson says the French novelist Michel Houellebecq is again under investigation by a judge, this time over 2022 remarks to the outlet Front Populaire. He says the investigation began with a 2023 complaint from the Grand Mosque of Paris and could lead to criminal charges, with a possible sentence of up to a year in prison and heavy fines. He notes Houellebecq was charged in 2002 with inciting racism over remarks on Islam and was found not guilty.

The remarks. Hankinson quotes three statements. Two are Houellebecq's opinions: that the native French want Muslims to stop "robbing and assaulting them" or leave, and that attacks on mosques and cafes frequented by Muslims will come if territories fall under Islamist control. The third is his view that the "great replacement" is "not a theory" but "statistical evidence." Hankinson calls the second unsavory but a prediction, not an incitement to violence, and calls the third a fact about shrinking Western populations and immigration. Those are the author's characterizations.

His argument. Hankinson says whether Houellebecq is right is not the issue. He writes that France, like Britain and Germany, has no First Amendment, and that people are routinely arrested there for speech that would be legal in America. He compares the climate to communist Czechoslovakia, where he says people learned not to speak out, and quotes comedian Rob Schneider on the cost of speaking up. He closes by urging Americans to hold to the First Amendment.

Why it matters here. The column links a European speech case to the U.S. debate over free speech and immigration, themes our readers follow, and we have covered the unrest in France.

What we could not check. Hankinson describes an investigation. Other outlets' headlines, including Breitbart and the Washington Examiner, say Houellebecq has been indicted or charged, and we did not read those pieces in full, so we cannot say which description is exact. We did not verify the quotes, the sentencing range, or the reasons for the French protests. The "great replacement" claim is contested, and the column's reading of it is his.

## Source

Original reporting: [Daily Wire (opinion)](https://www.dailywire.com/news/why-france-wants-to-jail-famous-novelist-over-wrongthink)
