Opinion: Sam Brownback Says His 2000 Vote to Open Trade With China Was the Worst of His 14 Senate Years and Urges Ending Permanent Trade Status, Fox News
Writing 25 years after China joined the WTO, the former senator proposes a 'Helsinki Accord 2.0': religious freedom for Chinese people in exchange for continued market access. This is his argument, not a news finding.
This is an opinion piece. We summarize the author's argument from Fox News Opinion; the claims are his, and we have not verified them. Fox's page credits the piece to Amb. Sam Brownback.
The confession. Brownback writes that in December 2001 China joined the World Trade Organization, which was only possible because the US had granted permanent normal trading relations a year earlier. He was one of 83 senators who voted for it, and he calls it "the worst vote I made in 14 years in the Senate."
The argument. He says the US believed a China integrated into the global economy would grow more open, and that this "has proven to be a tragic miscalculation." He accuses Beijing of genocide against Uyghurs, Tibetans and Falun Gong practitioners, says it leads an alliance of authoritarians, and says it is building up nuclear weapons and a navy larger than America's. He writes that "it is long past time to end China's access to permanent normal trade relations" and compares the moment to a new Cold War, arguing the US never gave the Soviet Union favored trade status and starved it of money to compete with Reagan's buildup.
The proposal. Brownback would first offer Beijing a deal he calls a "Helsinki Accord 2.0": allow religious freedom for all its people or the West begins to disengage its economies from China's. He says the loss of American markets would be devastating to China's economy, and that if China refuses, it builds the case for untangling the two economies. He cites an estimated 100 million Christians in China, along with Falun Gong practitioners, Tibet and Xinjiang.
The timing. Fox ran the piece the day President Trump left for Asia, where, as we reported earlier from CNN, he is due to meet Xi Jinping on Thursday. Brownback's column does not mention the trip.
What to weigh. This is a call for a policy change by a former senator who regrets his own vote. We did not check his figures on genocide, the number of Christians or the navy comparison, and the column offers no response from Beijing or from trade experts who support current policy.