Opinion: Robert Maginnis Says the Iran War Cost Republicans Congress and Trump Owes Voters a Plan to Finish It
In a Fox News opinion column, columnist Robert Maginnis compares Tuesday to the 2006 Iraq-war midterm and argues Trump must define victory in Iran. He does not call for surrender, and says Iran must not read the election as permission to threaten America.
A Fox News opinion column on Sunday argues the war is the reason Republicans lost Congress, and asks what it has achieved.
The argument. Robert L. Maginnis writes that voters punished Republicans over an unpopular Middle East war on Nov. 3, as they did over Iraq in 2006. He says Democrats took both chambers, flipping at least seven Senate seats including Texas, Ohio, Kansas and Iowa. He notes Vice President JD Vance's Nov. 4 line, "The reason we lost is the war," and Trump's reply that he "would have done nothing differently" because Iran cannot have a nuclear weapon. Maginnis agrees on the nuclear point.
His case. He says U.S. forces have done great damage to Iran's military, but that military success is not strategic success when the public loses confidence. He cites the Fox News Voter Poll, in which more than a third of voters called the war crucial to their House vote and about 6 in 10 said attacking Iran was the wrong decision. He cites a Pentagon estimate of $47.1 billion in war spending through Oct. 16, not counting base repairs, which he says the Wall Street Journal put at $5 billion to $15 billion. He also says sending a carrier to the Middle East leaves the western Pacific, and China, with less cover.
What he wants. A clear definition of victory: stopping a nuclear weapon, protecting shipping, a durable settlement or removing the regime. He says the administration is split, citing Axios on Vance and envoy Steve Witkoff favoring a deal and Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth and Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu favoring renewed strikes. He urges Trump to take in advisers who will challenge him, and notes that Bush replaced Rumsfeld after 2006.
The limit he sets. Maginnis says none of this counsels surrender. He writes that Iran's rulers "should not mistake the election for permission to threaten America," and points to Iranian parliament speaker Mohammad Baqer Qalibaf's claim that "Americans said NO TO WAR."
Why it matters here. A former Pentagon strategist writing in Fox's opinion section accepts the goal of stopping an Iranian bomb but questions the strategy, which adds to the debate on the right over what comes next.
What we could not check. This is opinion. We did not verify the Senate seat count, the poll figures, the cost estimates or the Axios account. Maginnis's description of his own past warnings is his own.