# Opinion: Dr. Qanta Ahmed Says Republicans Blur Muslims and Islamists, While Democrats Wave Off All Scrutiny as 'Islamophobia,' Fox News Reports

In a Fox News opinion column on Senator-elect Abdul El-Sayed, Ahmed argues both parties are failing a test and that he should answer questions on the Muslim Brotherhood and Israel. This is her opinion.

- Section: [Opinion](https://rightnewsrightnow.com/opinion/)
- Published: 2026-11-15
- By: RightNewsRightNow Staff
- Canonical page: https://rightnewsrightnow.com/articles/opinion-qanta-ahmed-el-sayed-first-muslim-senator-republicans-conflate-islam-islamism-democrats-dismiss-islamophobia-fox-news/

This is an opinion column by Dr. Qanta A. Ahmed in Fox News Opinion. The views and labels are hers, and we summarize them here. We read the full text.

Who she is. Ahmed describes herself as a Muslim woman, a physician and a longtime critic of Islamism, which she calls political Islam. She says she has treated and interviewed victims of Hamas, ISIS and the Taliban.

Her argument. She says the midterms, which sent Abdul El-Sayed, D-Mich., to the Senate as its first Muslim member-elect, put Islamism and anti-Muslim bigotry in the spotlight, and that both parties are failing the moment. Republicans, she writes, "too often fail to distinguish Muslims from Islamists," citing Vice President JD Vance calling El-Sayed "very, very evil," President Trump calling him a "jihadist," and Rep. Nancy Mace's comments about Muslims in office. She says such attacks alienate Muslim voters and undercut fair scrutiny. Democrats, she says, "seem unwilling to examine the distinction at all," and label legitimate questions "Islamophobia."

What she says El-Sayed should answer. She says he should be challenged on his views of the Muslim Brotherhood, Islamist movements, antisemitism and Israel's right to exist. She points to his appearance at an Arab America Foundation summit where, per Fox investigative reporter Asra Nomani, an event leader said "You destroyed AIPAC twice" and invoked "From the river to the sea" while he smiled; his appearance with commentator Hasan Piker, whom he later distanced himself from; his "hurt people hurt people" remark after a Michigan synagogue attack; and 2012 columns on Egypt's Muslim Brotherhood. She notes he rejects any claim that he or his family are Brotherhood affiliates.

Her conclusion. She says scrutiny must rest on verifiable evidence, not on a politician's faith, and that "rejecting Islamism isn't an act of anti-Muslim hatred." She also asks that Rep.-elect Adam Hamawy, D-N.J., be examined on his CNN answer about Iran.

Why it matters here. It is a conservative-leaning voice criticizing both parties' handling of a hot-button race, and it follows our coverage of El-Sayed and Hamawy.

What we could not check. We did not verify the quotes, the summit remarks, the 2012 columns or her characterizations. El-Sayed has denied the Brotherhood claims, and nothing in her column proves them.

## Source

Original reporting: [Fox News (opinion)](https://www.foxnews.com/opinion/americas-first-muslim-senator-exposes-political-blind-spot)
