Opinion: Matt Calkins Says Democrats' Push to Overturn Washington's Girls' Sports Vote Shows They Don't Care About Democracy, OutKick Column
In an OutKick column, Matt Calkins argues that Democrats who say democracy is on the ballot are already planning court and political fights to undo Washington's Initiative 638. He cites Rep. Pramila Jayapal, state party chair Shasti Conrad and a Seattle advocacy group.
An OutKick column argues Democrats are treating a voter-approved measure as an inconvenience. The author is Matt Calkins.
His opening. Calkins says Democratic politicians have used the word "democracy" constantly. He cites Kamala Harris's "democracy is on the ballot," Gavin Newsom's line that democracy is "under assault," and Hakeem Jeffries' pledge to "fight for our democracy." His question: why does democracy stop mattering when Democrats don't get what they want?
The measure. Washington's Initiative 638 would require K-12 sports teams to separate boys and girls. Calkins says it was not close: the AP called it when "yes" led by 13 points with 88 percent counted.
The response he cites. Calkins says Rep. Pramila Jayapal said at an election-night event, "We are going to take our state back," and that Democrats would plan "how we overturn these bad initiatives." He says Washington State Democratic Party Chair Shasti Conrad called the measure "unconstitutional on its face" and said the fight "is just beginning." He adds that Danni Askini of the Seattle group Gender Justice League told KUOW it is weighing legal options, and that a writer named Robert Cruickshank urged a court challenge plus a repeal campaign in an essay comparing I-638 to California's Proposition 8.
His argument. Calkins says protecting girls from "the athletically superior sex" is not the same as denying gay people the right to marry, because the latter "does not have a victim." He concedes that legal challenges to ballot measures are legitimate, but says it is telling that a vote is "the people have spoken" when it goes Democrats' way and "the people have spoken out of turn" when it doesn't. He says he was at the Washington state cross country finals on Saturday, where a boy who joined the girls' team midseason competed, and that several girls told him they were relieved they would not face the issue next season.
What we could not check. This is opinion. We did not verify the quotes or the vote margin, or whether any lawsuit has been filed. The column does not include a response from the Democrats or groups it names. We have covered the I-638 vote and the Washington cross country story in earlier articles.