RightNewsRight NowThe headlines that matter. Credited. Unspun.
RightNewsRight Now
Opinion

Opinion: Mark Goldfeder Says the Hegseth Impeachment Has a Legal Flaw Because the War Powers Resolution Binds the President, Daily Wire

Daily Wire guest column by Mark Goldfeder argues Massie's lead article charges Hegseth under a law that never mentions the Secretary, and that Democrats set a policy-fights-aren't-impeachable standard in 2024.

Illustration: RightNewsRightNow.

This is an opinion column by Dr. Mark Goldfeder, director of the National Jewish Advocacy Center, published by the Daily Wire. These are his arguments.

The main point. Goldfeder says the lead article of Rep. Thomas Massie's resolution accuses Hegseth of violating the War Powers Resolution, but the law never mentions the Secretary of Defense. He says every duty it sets outside Congress runs to the president: consulting Congress, reporting within 48 hours, ending force after 60 days. He says Massie's own articles admit the president gave the orders, for example by reciting that "President Donald J. Trump transmitted" the notification.

The standard. Goldfeder says a subordinate who carries out an order the president says is lawful has not abused his office unless the order was unlawful on its face. He says the only claim of illegality is that the order broke the War Powers Resolution, and that whether its 60-day clock is constitutional has been fought over since 1973 with no court ruling.

The Mayorkas precedent. He recalls that the Senate sustained Chuck Schumer's April 2024 point of order that the Mayorkas impeachment article did not allege a high crime or misdemeanor. Goldfeder quotes Schumer: "The Framers were clear: Impeachment should never be used to settle policy disagreements." He asks whether that standard was "a principle or a convenience."

Other defects. He says Article II relies on a concurrent resolution, which the Supreme Court's 1983 decision in INS v. Chadha says cannot bind the executive. He says Articles IV through VIII charge Hegseth with his own decisions, such as the Minab school strike, boat strikes, the Mark Kelly censure, the Maduro seizure and Yemen, but the resolution bundles all eight into one vote.

His alternative. Goldfeder says Congress could write a funding rider, since the current funding law expires Dec. 11, and that voters can punish the president at the ballot box.

What we could not check. We read the full column. We did not review the 34-page resolution or the statute. The column states that the vote comes by Wednesday and that Jeffries called himself a "hard yes," which we did not confirm. It does not give the case for the other side. These are Goldfeder's views, not ours.

More stories