Opinion: James Carter Argues Washington Pays Homeless Providers for Activity Instead of Results, Daily Wire
A Daily Wire column by a former White House economic aide cites a Cicero Institute report on HUD funding and backs an outcome-based approach. It is his view, and the column does not give the other side.
This is an opinion column. The views are the author's, not ours.
James Carter, a commissioner of The Growth Commission and a former associate director of the National Economic Council, argues that federal homelessness funding rewards motion over progress.
His case. Carter says "never confuse motion with action" describes Washington's approach: more spending, providers and services without more progress. He leans on a new Cicero Institute report that examined IRS filings from 1,458 nonprofit providers funded through HUD's Continuum of Care. He says their total revenue rose 123.9 percent from 2013 to 2024, against 34.7 percent inflation, while the national one-night count of people experiencing homelessness rose 30.7 percent. He adds that HUD Continuum of Care awards grew 67.3 percent between fiscal years 2018 and 2024.
The incentive. Under the traditional model, he says, grants largely pay for beds, housing units and services, and renewals depend more on compliance than on outcomes. He calls it essentially fee-for-service, where providers are paid to maintain services and not to reduce need. He notes the National Alliance to End Homelessness has asked for $9.6 billion more, including $4.8 billion for salary increases at homeless-service organizations, and says Congress should ask whether more money on the same terms will help.
The fix. Carter backs HUD's fiscal year 2026 shift. He says the funding notice makes 40 percent of renewal funding competitive, sets aside $1.3 billion for transitional housing and supportive services, and gives more weight to fewer people on the street, treatment, employment income and exits to housing without ongoing subsidies. He says the competition is proceeding under a First Circuit stay pending appeal after a district court vacated the notice. He says the changes guarantee nothing and HUD should publish performance data.
His conclusion. He says economic growth, which raises incomes and the tax base, is the most lasting way to expand society's capacity, and that federal grants should reward progress.
What we could not check. We read the full column. We did not verify the Cicero figures or the HUD notice details. Cicero's report is a policy group's analysis. The column gives no reply from providers or the Alliance, and says nothing on why counts rose.