Opinion: Hugh Hewitt Says Trump Needs Three Legal Answers Before January on Court Packing, D.C. Statehood and the Popular Vote Compact, Fox News
Fox News columnist Hugh Hewitt argues Trump should ask the Justice Department's Office of Legal Counsel to rule on three Democratic ideas before the new Congress is sworn in on Jan. 3.
Fox News contributor Hugh Hewitt says the White House should get its legal footing now, before Democrats take the House. His column argues the president should have the Justice Department put three questions to its Office of Legal Counsel (OLC) before the new Congress is sworn in on Jan. 3. This is opinion, and the views are his.
The setup. Hewitt starts with a Friday exchange. Rep. Robert Garcia, the incoming chair of House Oversight, posted that Chief of Staff Stephen Miller "should lawyer up." Attorney General Todd Blanche replied that Miller "already has a lawyer," meaning the Justice Department. Hewitt calls that the preview of "an epic clash" between Congress's Article I powers and the president's Article II powers, with the Supreme Court as referee.
The office. He says OLC, led by Assistant Attorney General T. Elliott Gaiser, is the executive branch's chief legal adviser and, unlike the Supreme Court, can give opinions on questions not yet in court. He expects a flood of executive privilege questions once Democratic committees, including Garcia's and Rep. Jamie Raskin's Judiciary panel, start issuing subpoenas, and says Trump should expect to follow Clinton, Obama and Biden in defending privilege.
The three questions. First, can Congress add justices to the Supreme Court? Hewitt argues "court packing" is arguably unconstitutional, pointing to the 1869 Judiciary Act, which set the Court at nine in the shadow of the 14th Amendment's due process guarantee. Second, would D.C. statehood require another constitutional amendment, given the 23rd Amendment? Third, is the National Popular Vote Interstate Compact constitutional? He cites Jonathan Turley's warning that one-party Democratic states could join it.
His limit. OLC opinions do not bind courts, Hewitt concedes, but he says they would shape the debate and could address who has standing and when a challenge is ripe.
What we could not check. We read the full column. These are Hewitt's views, not ours. We did not check the 1869 history, the quoted posts or the Turley piece, and the column does not give the case for the other side.