# Opinion: Miranda Devine Says Biden Bungled Afghan Vetting and Trump Must Order a Fresh Review, New York Post Column

In a New York Post column, Miranda Devine cites two federal whistleblowers who say 70,000 Afghan special visa holders were poorly vetted, with fake recommendation letters. She urges Trump to re-vet them before they can apply for citizenship. It is one writer's argument.

- Section: [Opinion](https://rightnewsrightnow.com/opinion/)
- Published: 2026-11-09
- By: RightNewsRightNow Staff
- Canonical page: https://rightnewsrightnow.com/articles/opinion-devine-afghan-vetting-fresh-review-new-york-post/

A New York Post opinion column argues the Trump administration should re-check every Afghan who came in on a special visa, before the first of them become eligible to apply for citizenship.

The setup. Columnist Miranda Devine writes that activists are in Washington this week asking Congress to admit more Afghans, on top of the 200,000 she says the Biden administration brought in after the 2021 withdrawal. She says at least four of Biden's evacuees have been arrested on terrorism charges.

The whistleblowers. Devine cites two unnamed federal whistleblowers who say more than 70,000 Afghans received Special Immigrant Visas with automatic green cards, and that those holders become eligible for citizenship in the next year. One says: "I have sleepless nights thinking there will be another 9/11 style terrorist attack." They told her the program required a year of "faithful service" to the U.S. government, but that potentially thousands of holders used faked letters. They estimate up to 2,000 letter-writers were paid between $3,500 and $40,000 per letter. She says one CIA official whose signature is on 12,300 letters, "Morgan A. Killington," never existed.

The cases she names. Devine points to Rahmanullah Lakanwal, who is charged in the Nov. 26 shooting of two West Virginia National Guard members in Washington that killed Army Spc. Sarah Beckstrom, 20, and badly wounded Staff Sgt. Andrew Wolfe, 24. He has pleaded not guilty. She also names Nasir Ahmad Tawhedi, who pleaded guilty to material support to ISIS over an Election Day 2024 plot in Oklahoma City, and two others charged with terror-related offenses. She says Lakanwal and Tawhedi both received Killington letters.

Official findings she cites. She quotes Sen. Chuck Grassley asking FBI Director Kash Patel about the letters in September, and says Patel answered that the FBI will keep vetting those individuals. She says a DHS inspector general report found a 40% error rate in deciding asylum claims in Biden's Operation Allies Welcome. She says a court last week stopped the deportation of more than 150 Afghans to Pakistan.

Her ask. Devine calls for a fresh review of all special visa holders. She quotes an advocate for the evacuees, Shawn VanDiver, calling the court ruling "a reprieve" and "just a pause."

What we could not check. This is opinion. We did not see the whistleblowers' evidence or verify the counts, the cost per letter, the inspector general finding or the court ruling. Devine's column does not include a response from the Afghan advocacy groups beyond VanDiver's quote.

## Source

Original reporting: [New York Post (opinion)](https://nypost.com/2026/11/08/opinion/biden-bungled-afghan-vetting-trump-needs-to-order-a-fresh-review/)
