# Opinion: David Marcus Says Ashley Moody Is the Biggest Republican Winner of the Midterm 'Debacle' and Florida Offers a Way Back

Fox News columnist David Marcus argues Sen. Ashley Moody held Florida by focusing on accountability and the American dream, and that her race points to a path for Republicans. It is his opinion, and he also notes Vice President Vance blames Iran for the losses.

- Section: [Opinion](https://rightnewsrightnow.com/opinion/)
- Published: 2026-11-08
- By: RightNewsRightNow Staff
- Canonical page: https://rightnewsrightnow.com/articles/opinion-david-marcus-ashley-moody-survived-blue-tsunami-gop-star-florida-desantis-vance-iran-fox-news/

Fox News columnist David Marcus says one Republican came out of last week's midterms stronger than she went in.

The argument. Marcus writes that Sen. Ashley Moody of Florida "defied national trends" for a GOP hold, and calls her the biggest Republican winner of the "Midterm debacle." He says Florida did not carry Moody, and Moody helped carry Florida. He rejects the idea that her win was automatic because the state is red, pointing out that Texas also looked red and turned blue.

What Moody says. She told Fox News Digital she "fought tooth and nail" to make Floridians know that what they have "can be dismantled in one cycle." She said her campaign rested on meeting voters where they were and on two messages, a government that is accountable and one that protects the pursuit of the American Dream.

The comparisons. Marcus notes Moody was elected attorney general twice, in 2018 by low single digits and in 2022 by 21 points, and says she did not carry the scandal baggage he attributes to Texas Attorney General Ken Paxton, who lost his Senate bid. He says she also outperformed Sen. Darlene Graham in South Carolina, who took her late brother Lindsey Graham's seat, a choice he says was driven by President Trump and that many believe cost Republicans the seat. He writes that Republicans will lose between seven and nine Senate seats and that Moody now moves up in seniority, with Sens. John Cornyn and Susan Collins gone. He adds that Rep. Byron Donalds was elected governor and credits Gov. Ron DeSantis with building the Florida brand.

The split he flags. Marcus quotes DeSantis saying many GOP voters stayed home because Republicans in Congress did not deliver on big promises. He says that is at odds with Vice President JD Vance's theory that those voters came out but voted for Democrats, mainly over the Iran war and the relationship with Israel. He calls sorting out which theory is right the first job for Republicans.

Why it matters here. This is the argument inside the party over why it lost and who should lead it, and it names two possible 2028 voices.

What we could not check. This is opinion. We did not verify the vote margins, seat counts or the characterization of the other races. Moody and DeSantis are quoted as Marcus printed them.

## Source

Original reporting: [Fox News (opinion)](https://www.foxnews.com/opinion/david-marcus-ashley-moody-survived-blue-tsunami-emerged-gop-star)
