Opinion: David Harsanyi Argues Pete Hegseth Does Not Deserve to Be Impeached, Washington Examiner
Harsanyi writes that Democrats want a scalp, that incompetence is not a high crime, and that impeaching Cabinet members has become political theater. It is his view, offered as opinion.
David Harsanyi writes in the Washington Examiner that War Secretary Pete Hegseth should not be impeached, whatever one thinks of his work. This is his opinion. We read the full column.
His read of the politics. Harsanyi says Democrats need a scalp, and that impeaching Trump a third time carries too much risk in a year about affordability. Hegseth, he writes, is the least popular member of the Cabinet in most polling, so impeaching him would please the base without angering independents. He notes that House Minority Leader Hakeem Jeffries is a "hard yes" on impeaching Hegseth in 2027.
The comparison. He argues Jeffries defended Lloyd Austin after Austin disappeared for weeks without telling Congress, and after the Afghanistan withdrawal in which a suicide bomber killed 13 American service members. Harsanyi says he is skeptical Hegseth was the best choice, but calls him "a lot more capable than Austin."
His case for Hegseth. He calls the opening phase of the Iran war "extraordinarily successful," saying the U.S. and Israel quickly took control of Iranian airspace, destroyed the navy and degraded Tehran's regional reach with few casualties. He blames the war's later fits and starts on political decisions. He also credits Hegseth with the operation that captured Nicolas Maduro, with removing progressive cultural programs from the military, and with all five active branches meeting recruiting targets last year.
The principle. Even if Hegseth were incompetent, Harsanyi writes, that is not a "high crime or misdemeanor." He calls Rep. Thomas Massie's failed article, which accused Hegseth of violating the War Powers Resolution, misplaced, since the president, not his Cabinet, is responsible for seeking congressional consent. He says that logic would have required impeaching defense secretaries under Reagan, Bush, Clinton and Obama. He compares it to the Mayorkas impeachment, which he says changed nothing, and concludes that such impeachments are "political kabuki theater" that degrade a constitutional process.
What we could not check. This is an argument, not a news report. The claims about the war and the polling are Harsanyi's, and he offers no Democratic response.