New York City Says It Has Billed Second-Home Owners More Than $500 Million Under Mamdani's Luxury Tax, but Only About 7,500 Bills Went Out, Fox News Reports
Fox says the city mailed far fewer bills than the roughly 17,000 notices sent in the summer. City officials gave no breakdown of how the total was reached, and the tax still faces legal challenges.
We read Fox News's Tuesday night report on New York City's second-home surcharge, and, for the Ken Griffin item, an OutKick piece by Ian Miller, which is written as commentary. Figures are the city's as Fox gives them. We did not see the city's data.
The claim. Mayor Zohran Mamdani wrote on X Tuesday: 'We've billed more than $500 million to owners of second homes worth more than $5 million. That's half a billion dollars to invest in a City that works for all New Yorkers.' Fox says the city's Department of Finance mailed about 7,500 tax bills, well below the roughly 17,000 initial notices sent over the summer. Officials said about 8,900 exemption applications were granted and about 1,600 extension applications were denied.
How it compares. Fox says the billed total exceeds the $500 million target Gov. Kathy Hochul outlined earlier this year, but officials did not provide a breakdown of how it was calculated across the roughly 7,500 properties. Fox notes an April report from the city comptroller's office estimated a version of the tax could raise about $500 million from more than 11,200 properties before exemptions and changes in owner behavior, and between about $340 million and $380 million after accounting for them. Mamdani told reporters last week the city remains 'confident in its ability to raise half a billion dollars per year.' Billed amounts are not the same as money collected, and Fox does not report collections.
The tax. The surcharge, approved by the state Legislature in May, is on a sliding scale by property value and applies to certain one- to three-family properties worth $5 million or more and to condos and co-ops worth $1 million or more, per Fox. Owners who qualify for exemptions do not pay.
The courts. Fox says a state appeals court unanimously dismissed a lawsuit over the rollout earlier this month, finding the homeowners lacked standing and overturning a lower-court order to restart implementation. Fox says the tax still faces other challenges, including on constitutionality. Fox asked the mayor's office and the Finance Department for comment.
A related sale. OutKick reports Citadel founder Ken Griffin has sold a $58 million New York apartment to Jets owner Woody Johnson, and still owns the penthouse Mamdani featured in an April video. Griffin told the New York Post, as OutKick quotes him, 'I wish Woody and his family many happy years in one of New York's great residences.' OutKick says the sale was to avoid the tax. The piece is commentary, and neither Griffin's reasons nor the sale price terms beyond $58 million are confirmed in the pieces we read.