Montana Judge Blocks Enforcement of the State's 2025 Law Defining Sex as Binary While a Lawsuit Proceeds, Montana Free Press Reports
Missoula County Judge Leslie Halligan says the plaintiffs are likely to show Senate Bill 437 violates privacy and equal protection rights. Gov. Greg Gianforte's office says Montana will defend the law.
We read the Montana Free Press report by Katie Fairbanks, distributed by the Associated Press and last updated at 5:41 p.m. UTC Wednesday (11:41 a.m. Central). Statements are quoted or described as the report gives them.
The ruling. The report says Missoula County District Court Judge Leslie Halligan on Tuesday granted a preliminary injunction that bars the state from enforcing a 2025 law defining sex as binary, based on a person's reproductive system, while the lawsuit goes on. A preliminary injunction is a temporary order, not a final ruling on the law. Helena-based Upper Seven Law brought the case for a group of transgender, intersex and Two Spirit Montanans.
The law. Senate Bill 437 rewrote many sections of Montana law to define "male," "female," "sex" and "gender," and says "gender" is a synonym for "sex" under the new definitions, not for gender identity, experienced gender, expression or role. Gov. Greg Gianforte signed it in March, nearly a year after the Legislature passed it. A House Republican spokesperson said the delay was meant to avoid entangling it in litigation over an earlier, similar law.
The earlier law. Senate Bill 458 of 2023 was declared unconstitutional twice: in June 2024 because its subject was not clear in its title, and in February 2025 because a judge found it violated the Montana Constitution's equal protection clause.
The judge's reasoning. Halligan wrote that the question is not whether the two bills have "precisely the same words," but whether the differences change the constitutional analysis. She found the "operative effect" appears to be the same: a "state-mandated binary classification of sex" that, under the earlier ruling, infringes on Montanans' right to define their own gender identity. She wrote that the plaintiffs are likely to succeed on claims that the law violates privacy and equal protection rights and that enforcement would cause ongoing irreparable harm. She said the injunction avoids uncertainty about the earlier orders and inconsistent enforcement.
Both sides. Molly Danahy, Upper Seven Law's litigation director, said the Legislature made "a second attempt to pass essentially the same law" and "took unprecedented steps to avoid judicial review." The governor's office generally does not comment on litigation and pointed to a spring statement from Gianforte and House Speaker Brandon Ler. That statement says the law "codifies the long-recognized, commonsense, immutable, biologically-based definition of sex," protects people born intersex, and does not stop transgender people from identifying as they wish, though not as to sex. It says the state will defend the law.
The timeline. The suit was filed April 6, the state responded May 22, and a hearing was held June 19 in Missoula. The state argued the new law differs from the 2023 one and does not demand private information. The plaintiffs argued it forces them to disclose private medical details.
What we could not check. We read the report, not the injunction order. We do not know whether the state will appeal.