RightNewsRight NowThe headlines that matter. Credited. Unspun.
RightNewsRight Now
Culture

Meta, Google and TikTok Sue California to Block a Law Banning 'Addictive Features' for Users Under 16, Breitbart Reports

Breitbart, citing the New York Post, says all three companies filed separate federal suits Wednesday against AB 1709, which takes effect Jan. 1. Penalties run up to $50,000 per affected minor. California's attorney general says he will defend the law.

Illustration: RightNewsRightNow.

Three of the biggest names in social media are asking federal courts to stop a California child-safety law before it starts, Breitbart reports.

The suits. Meta, Google (with YouTube) and TikTok each filed their own lawsuit Wednesday against California Attorney General Rob Bonta over Assembly Bill 1709, which Gov. Gavin Newsom signed Sept. 10. The law takes effect Jan. 1. Meta and Google sued in the Northern District of California, and TikTok sued in Los Angeles.

What the law does. Breitbart says platforms must verify ages and delete the accounts of anyone under 16 unless those accounts are stripped of features the state calls addictive, including personalized feeds and autoplay. Knowing violations carry penalties up to $50,000 per affected minor, and negligent ones $25,000. It goes further than a 2024 law, SB 976, which let parents consent to personalized feeds for under-18s. AB 1709 has no parental-consent exception. All three companies are already fighting SB 976 at the Ninth Circuit.

The companies' case. Meta argues the First Amendment protects editorial judgment about how speech is shown, and that the law unfairly exempts streaming services and review sites such as Yelp. It says it will roll out default limits for California teens that only parents can change, including a two-hour daily cap, an overnight block and muted notifications during school hours. Google says autoplay is already off by default for YouTube users under 18 and that without personalized feeds younger users would struggle to find suitable videos among the 20 million videos uploaded daily. TikTok calls the law "blatantly unconstitutional" and says it takes away parents' right to decide what is appropriate. All three also argue federal Section 230 protections override the law.

The state's answer. Bonta's office said it is reviewing the filings and is "committed to defending California's commonsense laws to protect kids online."

Why it matters here. The fight sets parents' control against government control of what teens see online. The companies argue the state is replacing parents' judgment, and the state says it is protecting kids.

What we could not check. We did not read the complaints or the New York Post story. The quotes and penalty figures are Breitbart's account. We have not seen the text of AB 1709, and we cannot say how a court will rule.

More stories