RightNewsRight NowThe headlines that matter. Credited. Unspun.
RightNewsRight Now
Politics

Justices Thomas and Alito Dissent as the Supreme Court Turns Away a Challenge to California's Implicit-Bias Training Rule for Doctors' Courses, Fox News Reports

Thomas wrote that states cannot regulate their way out of the First Amendment. California says teachers are free to disagree. Gorsuch also would have taken the case but did not explain why.

Illustration: RightNewsRightNow.

We read Fox News's Monday report on the Supreme Court's order and Justice Clarence Thomas's dissent. We did not read the order or the dissent itself.

The case. Fox says the court declined on Monday to hear a petition from Dr. Azadeh Khatibi, a California physician who teaches a mandatory continuing-education course. California requires licensed doctors to complete 50 hours of state-approved courses every two years, and requires those courses to include instruction on implicit bias, either through examples of how it affects treatment and health outcomes or through strategies for addressing how it feeds healthcare disparities. Khatibi sued with the nonprofit Do No Harm, arguing the state forces private teachers to deliver its message. Her lawyers wrote that she does not want to cover implicit bias, that it is not relevant to her topics, and that she disagrees it is the main driver of disparities in care.

The dissent. Thomas, joined by Justice Samuel Alito, dissented from the refusal. "When, as here, the government does not issue its own messages but instead requires private speakers to communicate the government's viewpoint, the First Amendment applies," he wrote. "A State cannot regulate its way out of First Amendment scrutiny." He warned against letting the government-speech doctrine become "a cover for censorship" or a "cloak for compelled speech." He also asked whether California could require a keynote speaker at a state legal conference to oppose racial preferences in law firm hiring. Justice Neil Gorsuch also dissented from the decision not to take the case, but he did not join Thomas and Alito's argument, and his reasons are not public, Fox says.

California's answer. The state argued that instructors need only include a discussion of implicit bias and do not have to endorse it, and that they can say they disagree. In its brief, Fox quotes, "instructors who do not believe that implicit bias exists are free to say so," and they may tell attendees that the topic is there only to meet state rules. California said states need wide authority over what doctors must do to keep their licenses. Thomas replied that the rule "leaves petitioners no choice but to discuss the topic in a way that affirms the State's view."

The lower court. Fox says the Ninth Circuit ruled last year that continuing medical education counts as government speech because the state regulates the profession so heavily, which meant the First Amendment's speech scrutiny did not apply. The Supreme Court's order leaves that ruling standing, but does not decide whether the requirement is constitutional.

Why it matters here. Thomas's point is that the logic could stretch to many licensed trades, not just doctors. Three justices wanted the court to say something.

What we could not check. The vote count beyond the three dissenters is not given in Fox's report. A refusal to hear a case is not a ruling on the merits, and we cannot say why the other justices declined.

More stories