Judge Denies the New York Times' Bid to Dismiss Trump's $15 Billion Defamation Suit, Letting Four Counts Go Forward, Fox News Reports
Fox News says Judge Steven Merryday dismissed two counts and 27 challenged statements but let claims over seven accusations of criminal conduct proceed. The Times calls the remaining claim meritless.
This is breaking news. We read the Fox News report by Brian Flood, published at 7:02 p.m. Eastern Thursday (6:02 p.m. Central). Quotes and details are as Fox News reports them, and the court order itself was not available to us.
The ruling. Fox News says U.S. District Judge Steven D. Merryday denied a motion by The New York Times to dismiss President Donald Trump's $15 billion defamation lawsuit. The judge allowed four counts, centered on seven specific accusations of criminal conduct, to move forward. Trump's lawyers argue that the Times and publisher Penguin Random House showed reckless disregard, alleging "purposeful avoidance of the truth," in a book written by Times journalists.
What was thrown out. Fox News says Merryday also dismissed two counts, threw out 27 other challenged statements as not actionable under the strict First Amendment protections of New York Times Co. v. Sullivan, and denied Trump's request to amend his complaint a third time. In other words, the suit survives in a narrowed form.
The judge's reasoning. According to Fox News, Merryday criticized Susanne Craig and Russ Buettner, the authors of "Lucky Loser: How Donald Trump Squandered His Father's Fortune and Created the Illusion of Success," for publishing definitive claims of complex tax fraud and money laundering without a formal legal opinion or forensic audit. Fox News says the judge noted the accusations against Trump and his father were made without charges or convictions. It quotes him writing that the complaint's facts "create at least a plausible inference that the authors and the publishers knew that no reliable conclusion about violations of the tax laws, including especially the estate and gift tax laws, is possible without reliance on qualified opinion" that they "knowingly failed to obtain." Fox News says the court rejected the Times' reliance on outside commentators, such as one who said a transaction "smells like a crime."
Trump's side. A spokesman for Trump's legal team told Fox News Digital that Merryday "has correctly denied the motion to dismiss" and that the defendants "will now have to answer for intentionally and maliciously defaming President Trump."
The Times' side. A Times spokesperson told Fox News Digital the paper is "encouraged to see Judge Merryday's dismissal of almost all claims against us," and that it believes "the remaining claim in the filing has no legal merit." Fox News says the judge ordered the Times to file a formal answer within 28 days.
What we could not check. We did not read the ruling or the complaint. The description of which counts survived is Fox News' summary, and a ruling to let a claim proceed is not a finding that any statement was defamatory.