Judge Refuses to Dismiss Alex Murdaugh's Original Murder Indictments, Clearing the Way for His April Retrial, ABC News and AP Report
Judge Debra McCaslin ruled Friday after a Nov. 13 hearing. AP says she faulted a former SLED agent for not reading a lab report but found his mistakes were not intentional and that other evidence supported the charges.
This is breaking news. We read ABC News's full report from Friday evening and the Associated Press report as carried by the Orlando Sentinel (we saw the opening of the AP piece, not all of it). We did not read the judge's written order.
The ruling. A South Carolina judge on Friday refused to dismiss the original murder indictments against Alex Murdaugh in the killings of his wife and son, AP says. Judge Debra McCaslin's decision clears the way for the retrial, set for April 5, 2027, in Sumter County, after she granted a change of venue, ABC News reports.
What the defense argued. The ruling followed a Nov. 13 hearing. Murdaugh's lawyers argued that the chief investigator, former State Law Enforcement Division agent David Owen, lied to a Colleton County grand jury in 2022 about blood spatter being found on Murdaugh's T-shirt, and that he inaccurately said other guns on the property were loaded like the shotgun used to kill Paul Murdaugh. ABC says no transcript of the grand jury session exists, so defense attorney Jim Griffin relied on Owen's own statements and his testimony at the first trial. ABC says Owen testified at that trial that he did not see a report finding no human blood on the shirt until after the indictment, and that he was not trying to trick grand jurors.
What the judge wrote. AP says McCaslin wrote that any mistakes by Owen were not intentional and that other evidence was enough to support the indictments. She said she was disappointed that Owen did not read the report saying there was no blood on the shirt before he went to the grand jury. "Law enforcement bears a fundamental duty to thoroughly review and accurately represent the complete evidentiary record," she wrote. "Oversights of this nature undermine public confidence in the integrity of the criminal justice system." AP says she added that inconsistencies in the evidence are matters for trial and cross-examination.
The state's case. ABC says prosecutor Creighton Waters argued the spatter claims were believed true at the time and that far stronger evidence would have gone before the grand jury, including a video from Paul Murdaugh's phone that Waters said has audio of Paul, Maggie and Alex Murdaugh together moments before the killings. ABC says prosecutors had said they were ready to seek new indictments as soon as next month if the defense had won.
Background. The South Carolina Supreme Court overturned Murdaugh's 2023 murder convictions and life sentences earlier this year, citing what it called "shocking jury interference" by the court clerk, ABC reports. ABC says he remains in prison after pleading guilty to separate financial crimes, with sentences of 27 years on state charges and 40 years on federal charges, and has denied killing his wife, Maggie, 52, and son Paul, 22.
What we could not check. We did not read the order, so the judge's quotes are as AP printed them.
Sources: ABC News, https://abc11.com/story/judge-denies-alex-murdaughs-bid-dismiss-murder-charges/20060596 and The Associated Press, https://orlandosentinel.com/2026/11/20/alex-murdaugh-murder-charges-indictment-judge