# Daily Caller, Citing Politico, Says Incoming House GOP Leaders Are Discussing a Rule to Discipline Members Who Defy the Party Once It Is in the Minority

Rep. Mike Simpson says the idea came up at Tuesday's closed-door leadership election. Rep. Anna Paulina Luna says it would amount to leadership trying to 'control us.' No rule has been announced.

- Section: [Politics](https://rightnewsrightnow.com/politics/)
- Published: 2026-11-14
- By: RightNewsRightNow Staff
- Canonical page: https://rightnewsrightnow.com/articles/house-republicans-minority-weigh-discipline-rule-punish-members-who-break-with-leadership-jim-jordan-simpson-luna-politico-daily-caller/

House Republicans may get stricter with their own members once they lose the majority, the Daily Caller reports. We read the Caller's full text. The underlying reporting is Politico's, which we did not see.

The idea. The Caller says incoming Minority Leader Jim Jordan and others in the coming leadership team are weighing tougher treatment of holdouts who vote against the party's agenda, even from the minority. Sources told Politico it could set a precedent for when the party takes the majority back. Idaho Rep. Mike Simpson said several colleagues raised it during Tuesday's closed-door leadership election. He said he had never seen so many internal rebellions as Republicans faced over the last two years, and that many members want to head that off.

The record. The Caller says nine rules votes failed under Speaker Mike Johnson, and none failed under Nancy Pelosi. It says Republican leaders rarely threatened real penalties, such as removing someone from a committee, while Democratic leaders did. It points to Democratic leaders asking a caucus panel to take up Reps. Jared Golden and Marie Gluesenkamp Perez after they helped pass a rule in September. It also recalls Pelosi denying former Rep. Kathleen Rice a Judiciary Committee seat after Rice voted against her for speaker.

The pushback. Rep. Anna Paulina Luna, a Florida Republican, told Politico she opposes the move. "There's a difference between going against a rule and effectively preventing us from being able to legislate," she said. "They're effectively trying to control us." The Caller notes Luna and 12 other Republicans voted against a procedural vote tied to attaching the SAVE America Act to the defense bill, and that 19 Republicans, among them Reps. Tim Burchett, Thomas Massie and Lauren Boebert, voted with Democrats against reauthorizing Section 702 of the surveillance law known as FISA.

The response. The offices of Jordan, Whip Tom Emmer and Conference Chair Lisa McClain did not immediately respond to the Daily Caller News Foundation.

What we could not check. The talk of a rule is as Politico's sources and Simpson describe it, as relayed by the Caller. Nothing has been proposed in writing that we have seen, and no vote has been scheduled. The Caller's list of what leaders have not done, including on Flock cameras and Iran, is the Caller's framing, not ours.

## Source

Original reporting: [Daily Caller](https://dailycaller.com/2026/11/13/house-republicans-minority-jim-jordan-discipline-members)
