Colorado Federal Judge Holds ICE Officials in Contempt for Re-Arresting Immigrants Minutes After Court-Ordered Release, Says Agency 'Made a Mockery' of Orders but Declines Further Action, CPR News Reports
CPR News says at least 18 people in Colorado were held too long or re-arrested within minutes of a release order in six weeks. The judge imposed no sanction because an official swore the practice had stopped.
We read the Colorado Public Radio report by Allison Sherry, published Wednesday, Nov. 18. Reuters and NBC News carried the same ruling, and we link only the CPR report we read. Details are as CPR reports them, and ICE's side is thin in what we saw.
The ruling. CPR says U.S. District Judge Charlotte Sweeney held ICE officials in contempt Wednesday in a 15-page ruling for repeatedly violating court orders by re-detaining immigrants after judges had ordered them freed. In the ruling she wrote, "ICE's new 'policy' of immediately re-detaining petitioners following release made a mockery of court orders mandating petitioners' immediate release." CPR says at least 18 people in Colorado, and by attorneys' estimates more, were held longer than they should have been or re-arrested within minutes of release in the past six weeks.
The case. CPR says the case before Sweeney involved Ramon Quintero Alvarez, born in Mexico, who came to the U.S. with his mother between 1993 and 1994 and has lived in Wyoming for 12 years with two American-born sons. The Colorado U.S. Attorney's Office, led by Peter McNeilly, did not show cause by Oct. 27 for keeping him detained. He was released and immediately re-detained after a few steps, which Sweeney said was unlawful.
The testimony. CPR says Nichole Black, an assistant field office director for ICE's Enforcement and Removal Operations, testified she "received a direct order" from her supervisor to re-detain people "that had some type of criminality." Sweeney wrote that Black believed it was permissible to escort someone to a public area and re-detain them despite a court order, and in the court's words her belief "must shock any reader." Black's supervisor, Nathan Rasper, said he felt bound to "make lawful arrests" and had heard of a Minnesota policy allowing re-arrest.
No sanction. CPR says Rasper told the judge at an earlier hearing this month that he had stopped the practice. Sweeney wrote that, because the government "cured the contempt by ceasing the practice at issue," the court declines further action. CPR says the ruling carries no fine or other remedy but signals she would reopen the matter if orders are violated again. McNeilly had no comment Wednesday.
What we could not check. We did not read the 15-page order, and we have no comment from ICE or the Department of Homeland Security. The count of at least 18 is CPR's, and attorneys say the real figure may be higher.