A Federal Judge in Boston Strikes Down the Trump Administration's Rule Capping Foreign Student Visas at a Fixed Term, Saying DHS Overstepped Its Authority, Fox News Reports
Judge F. Dennis Saylor IV, a George W. Bush appointee, ruled Monday that the rule is not backed by the statute. A DHS spokesperson calls the outrage 'performative.' DHS did not say whether it will appeal.
This is breaking. We read Fox News's Tuesday report on Monday's ruling. We did not read the opinion itself, so the judge's words are as Fox quotes them and the characterizations of the rule are Fox's.
The ruling. Fox says US District Judge F. Dennis Saylor IV of Massachusetts ruled Monday that the Department of Homeland Security overstepped its authority with a rule that placed greater restrictions on visas for international students, exchange visitors and foreign journalists. Fox calls it a victory for the labor unions and university presidents who sued, and another loss in the administration's legal push to crack down on immigration. Saylor had blocked the rule from taking effect in September. Monday's ruling goes further and strikes it down entirely, after finding that DHS violated federal administrative law.
What the rule would have done. Fox says it would have replaced a longstanding policy with a fixed period of study, generally capped at four years, with a request for an extension required to stay longer. Before, there was no fixed time limit as long as a student stayed enrolled and kept legal status. It also would have added limits on transferring schools, changing programs and pursuing additional degrees, plus extra immigration reviews meant to catch fraud and national security risks.
The judge's reasoning. Saylor wrote: 'Put bluntly, DHS is seeking to prevent or discourage the very activity, providing educational opportunities for foreign students in the United States, that Congress sought to permit and encourage.' He wrote that the statute 'does not grant DHS such broad and open-ended authority to undermine the F-1 visa program,' and that DHS has not explained how a discretionary renewal system after four years 'meaningfully enhances the ability of DHS to root out cases of fraud.' Fox notes he gave an example: a student who earns a J.D. and later wants an M.B.A.
DHS's response. Lawyers for the department argued that open-ended stays prevent officials from periodically checking that visa holders are following the rules, and that required extensions would create more chances to find fraud and security risks. A DHS spokesperson told Fox: 'The performative outrage is incredible. Where was the outrage when foreign nationals were abusing the system?' The spokesperson said the media should thank the president for cracking down on fraud. Fox says DHS did not say whether it will appeal.
The judge. Fox describes Saylor as a Bush appointee, notes a 2014 profile identified him as a Republican, and says he was confirmed with bipartisan support, including from Sen. Ted Kennedy.
What we could not check. We have not read the opinion or the DHS filings. Fox's text does not say whether or when an appeal will be filed.