Federal Judge Overrides Mamdani's Objections and Orders New York City to Comply With ICE Subpoena for Bronx Homeless Shelter Records, Washington Examiner Reports
Judge Lewis Kaplan ruled the city must hand over names and birth dates, narrowed by a special master to residents with serious criminal histories. City lawyers had argued the subpoena undercuts sanctuary laws. The Mamdani team and Attorney General James are weighing an appeal.
A federal judge has sided with ICE in a fight over New York City shelter records, the Washington Examiner reports.
The ruling. U.S. District Judge Lewis Kaplan, appointed by President Bill Clinton, ruled Friday that the city must comply with an Immigration and Customs Enforcement subpoena. ICE wants names and birth dates of homeless men at a Bronx shelter, to check whether any are in the country illegally and subject to deportation.
The safeguard. The federal government agreed to a special master who would pick out residents with "certain serious criminal histories" and pass only those names to the agency. In a 12-page order, Kaplan wrote that the city "has not shown that producing this list would be unduly burdensome" and that, under the case law, the court "has no choice but to compel the subpoena's enforcement, as modified." Both sides have two weeks to propose an order on the special master's appointment and pay.
The city's argument. The Mamdani administration said the subpoena would "circumvent and undermine" its sanctuary city laws, which limit cooperation with federal immigration agents. A spokesperson said the city is weighing an appeal. State Attorney General Letitia James told Politico, "I'm familiar with the ruling and we're reviewing the possibility of an appeal."
The wider fight. The Examiner says Mayor Zohran Mamdani remains opposed to ICE in the five boroughs, citing an Oct. 8 shooting in which an immigration officer wounded a Dominican national in Marble Hill. After the midterms, Mamdani said the country should "start with a chapter of humanity." The Examiner links this to a report that Houston's mayor is limiting police cooperation with ICE, which we covered earlier.
Why it matters here. The order is narrow. Only residents with serious criminal histories would be named, and a court-appointed official screens the list.
What we could not check. We did not read the order. The quotes come from the Examiner. We did not verify the Marble Hill shooting details or the number of residents involved, which the report does not give.