# Federal Judge Refuses to Release Oscar Belgal, the Dominican Man Shot by Immigration Agents in New York While Driving His 5-Year-Old Son, AP Reports

AP says Judge Hector Gonzalez found a possible procedural error but not one that requires release. Belgal, 28, can still ask the immigration court for bond; his lawyers say the agents had no valid warrant.

- Section: [Border & Security](https://rightnewsrightnow.com/border-security/)
- Published: 2026-11-21
- By: RightNewsRightNow Staff
- Canonical page: https://rightnewsrightnow.com/articles/federal-judge-gonzalez-denies-release-oscar-belgal-shot-by-ice-agents-new-york-october-8-five-year-old-son-procedural-error-bond-ap/

We read the Associated Press report by Philip Marcelo and Gene Johnson, updated the evening of November 20, 2026. The two sides disagree sharply on the facts of the shooting, and we have attributed each version.

The ruling. AP reports that U.S. District Court Judge Hector Gonzalez on Friday declined to free Oscar Belgal from federal custody. Belgal, 28, a Dominican national, was shot and wounded by immigration officers during his arrest in New York last month. In a written ruling, Gonzalez said agents may have made a procedural error by serving an arrest warrant before Belgal received a notice to appear in immigration court. He called it a technical error that does not require release while deportation proceedings continue. He also rejected the argument that the agents lacked a valid warrant, and said a petition for release is not the right place to argue excessive force. AP says Belgal can still ask the immigration court for bond.

The record. AP says Belgal entered the U.S. illegally in 2021 and was arrested about two years later on robbery and other charges, eventually pleading guilty to grand larceny and receiving probation. He was arrested again in 2025 on allegations of attempting to sell controlled substances, a case that is still pending.

The shooting. On Oct. 8, ICE agents found Belgal as he drove his 5-year-old son home from school, AP says. Security camera footage released by the NYPD shows a plainclothes officer run to the car with a gun drawn and use the barrel to smash the driver's window. A second officer draws a gun as Belgal pulls away. The chase ends moments later with his bullet-riddled car stopped. AP says Belgal was hit in the shoulder and neck and his son was not hurt.

Two accounts. Federal officials say the officers fired because they believed their lives were in danger, and that Belgal hit two government vehicles and "accelerated toward other officers." His attorneys say the agents had no valid warrant and never identified themselves, and that Belgal did not learn they were ICE until he woke in the hospital. The Legal Aid Society, which represents him, called his continued detention "unconscionable."

What we could not check. We did not see the video or the court filings, and we could not verify either account of the shooting.

## Source

Original reporting: [The Associated Press](https://apnews.com/article/ice-shooting-new-york-dominican-republic-immigration-45aab0350d7621efd2418a76f34d162e)
