Energy Department Again Orders a Michigan Coal Plant to Stay Open Past Its Retirement Date, Defying an Appeals Court Ruling, AP Reports
Secretary Chris Wright issued the seventh emergency order for the J.H. Campbell plant since May 2025. Environmental groups say it costs ratepayers more than $600,000 a day. The department wants the full court to rehear the case.
A story on energy policy and electricity bills. We read the Associated Press's Monday report. Cost figures are the environmental groups' own and are described as theirs.
The order. AP says Energy Secretary Chris Wright issued an emergency order late Friday extending the operation of the 64-year-old J.H. Campbell Generating Plant near Grand Rapids, Michigan, past its scheduled retirement. He said the plant is needed to prevent blackouts and keep power reliable. AP counts it as the seventh such order for the plant since May 2025.
The court fight. AP says the order defies a September decision by a three-judge panel of the U.S. Court of Appeals for the D.C. Circuit, which sided with states and environmental groups and said there was no real emergency under the law. The Energy Department says it disagrees and has asked the full court to rehear the case. AP says a decision on that request is pending and the dispute could reach the Supreme Court. Michigan, Illinois and Minnesota are among the states that sued.
The cost claims. Environmental groups say there is no evidence the plant was ever needed to avoid a grid emergency, and that the extension costs Midwest families more than $600,000 a day. AP says a "Burning Money" tracker compiled by the group puts the cost to ratepayers of the administration's orders for fossil fuel plants in six states at more than $600 million, with over half of it from Campbell. Jessi Eidbo of the Sierra Club called the order "yet another illegal and expensive extension." Ted Kelly of the Environmental Defense Fund said the administration "keeps putting its thumb on the scale for costly coal."
The wider push. AP places the order among the administration's moves to help the coal industry, including a plan announced in June to spend nearly $700 million to support coal plants and exports, and EPA repeals of limits on greenhouse gas emissions from coal and gas power plants.
What we could not check. We have not seen the order or the tracker's math. The department's reasoning is as AP summarizes it.