David Beckham's Company Sues Coty for at Least $41 Million Over Fragrances Allegedly Sold in a Gas Station Bargain Bin and at Poundland, AP Reports; Coty Disputes the Claim
AP says the April filing accuses Coty of cheapening the brand. Coty denies it, asks for dismissal and says the suit is a way to exit the license and move to another firm.
We read the Associated Press report by Jill Lawless, last updated at 4:21 p.m. UTC Tuesday. Claims below are allegations by the parties, as AP reports them.
The claim. AP says DB Ventures, David Beckham's commercial company, has sued the German beauty group Coty in the New York Supreme Court. Coty makes and distributes Beckham-branded fragrances and toiletries, including the Classic and Instinct lines and the Intimately and Exquisite Leather eaux de toilette. DB Ventures says the products were found for sale in discount stores and in a gas station's bargain bin, and seeks at least $41 million in damages for breach of the licensing agreement.
The language. The filing says Beckham's brand is 'synonymous with excellence and refinement.' It says the company felt 'shock and dismay' to find the products in a gas station, and asks: 'How could this possibly have happened? Desperation and greed.' AP says the lawyers allege the goods ended up at British budget retailer Poundland, 'allowing the product to be sold for dollar store prices.'
Coty's answer. AP says Coty has asked a judge to dismiss the suit, which was filed in April. It argues New York courts lack jurisdiction and says DB Ventures is using the claim to 'manufacture its early exit' from the license and hand the Beckham contracts to another firm, Interparfums. Coty told AP: 'Coty strongly disputes the claims and has asked the court to dismiss them. As this is an ongoing legal matter, we will not comment further.' DB Ventures' parent, Authentic Brands, declined to comment.
The man behind the brand. AP notes Beckham, who played for Manchester United and Real Madrid and captained England, co-owns Inter Miami and was knighted last year. It cites the Sunday Times Rich List estimate of the Beckhams' wealth at almost 1.2 billion pounds ($1.58 billion).
What we could not check. We did not read the complaint or Coty's motion. The jurisdiction and motive claims are Coty's, and the pricing allegations are DB Ventures'. Neither has been decided by a court.