Fox News: Connecticut Teacher Fighting Over a Classroom Crucifix Heads to a Federal Appeals Court Dec. 7
Fox says Marisol Arroyo-Castro lost her bid for an injunction in 2025 and will argue before the Second Circuit. The school district says the dispute is about more than the crucifix.
A religious-expression case now has a court date, Fox News reports. This article goes beyond the short video clip we noted earlier this week. We read Fox's full text.
The case. Marisol Arroyo-Castro, a teacher for more than 30 years, says she was escorted out of her Connecticut school with a crucifix in a box after refusing to take it down. Her lawyers will argue Dec. 7 before the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit in New York City.
The timeline. Fox says administrators at DiLoreto Elementary and Middle School in New Britain told her in December 2024 to remove a crucifix she had kept near her desk for about a decade. She got a formal reprimand for insubordination Dec. 11, 2024. The next day officials removed the crucifix and suspended her for two days without pay. She was put on paid leave Dec. 16 and moved to a non-teaching job in March 2025. She sued in January 2025. A federal judge denied a preliminary injunction in November 2025, finding she was unlikely to win because the display counted as government speech.
Her side. First Liberty Institute attorney Becky Rees Dummermuth says the argument will be that the display was private speech. She points to the Supreme Court's Kennedy decision on Coach Joe Kennedy's prayer, and says schools must treat teachers equally if others may put personal items near their desks.
The district's side. A spokesperson says the matter extends beyond a religious symbol, citing an independent report that the district says found a broader pattern of statements and actions that concerned it about students of other religions. Fox says that report included interviews with four teachers and school leaders and repeated student claims that she referred to God, Jesus and religion inappropriately. The district says it offered other ways for her to practice her faith. First Liberty replies that the district said she could return if she took the crucifix down, and that its stated concern was an Establishment Clause problem that Kennedy answers. Arroyo-Castro denies making such references during class, per the report.
What we could not check. We did not see the district's report ourselves. The page we read did not show a publication date. The appeal concerns preliminary relief, not a final ruling.