Breitbart Says the Fed's Own Economic Model Shows Tariffs Can Lift Growth, Challenging a Harvard Economist's Simulation
Breitbart's John Carney says restoring one standard equation in the FRB/US model turns a 0.22 percent GDP loss from a 10 percent tariff into a 0.28 percent gain. It is Breitbart's own run, not a Fed finding.
Breitbart's John Carney argues that the Federal Reserve's main economic model, FRB/US, shows tariffs can raise growth and investment, in a Business Digest column. This is Breitbart's analysis. We read the full text.
The claim. Carney says a broad 10 percent tariff on non-oil goods leaves real GDP about 0.28 percent higher after ten years if foreign producers absorb just over 1 percent of the tariff bill, and that business investment also ends up higher.
The challenge. He is responding to Harvard economist Jason Furman's published "alternative histories" simulations. Furman's version has a permanent 10 percent tariff leaving GDP about 0.22 percent lower after ten years and investment down 3.51 percent, with Americans bearing the whole cost.
The adjustment. Carney says the gap comes from one change Furman made. In the standard model, higher domestic selling prices encourage firms to expand. Furman replaced that investment-price equation with one holding the relative price on its baseline, because the standard result seemed implausible to him. Carney stresses that Furman is open about it.
The rerun. Carney restored the standard equation while keeping Furman's surcharge on imported equipment. With foreigners absorbing none of the tariff, he says ten-year GDP is about 0.27 percent above baseline and the investment loss shrinks to 0.075 percent. When foreign suppliers absorb 4 percent of equipment duties, which he puts at 1.16 percent of the total, GDP is 0.282 percent higher and investment 0.016 percent higher. At 30 years, he reports GDP 0.21 percent higher and investment 0.42 percent higher. He says his runs leave out any reshoring or new export gains.
What we could not check. These are Carney's runs, not a Fed publication, and we did not rerun the model. Carney himself says mainstream economists have long been hostile to tariffs, and one column does not settle that debate.