Bill Essayli, Whose Own Authority Is Under Court Challenge, Is Tapped to Lead the Mar-a-Lago Raid Investigation, Fox News Reports
Fox News says Essayli replaces two prosecutors who left the 'grand conspiracy' probe. A judge ruled in October that he was unlawfully serving as U.S. attorney in Los Angeles.
This is breaking news. We read the Fox News report by Elaine Mallon, published at 3:21 p.m. Eastern Thursday (2:21 p.m. Central). Fox News bases the assignment on two sources it does not name. Details are as Fox News reports them.
The assignment. Fox News says two sources familiar with the investigation confirmed that Bill Essayli, the First Assistant U.S. Attorney for the Central District of California, will serve as a special assistant tasked with investigating whether Biden Justice Department officials broke federal law when carrying out the search warrant at Mar-a-Lago in 2022. That search began the classified documents case brought by former special counsel Jack Smith. Fox News says Essayli keeps his Los Angeles job and will split his time between Florida and Los Angeles.
The wider probe. Fox News says the Mar-a-Lago inquiry is part of a broader Justice Department probe. It says Attorney General Pam Bondi launched the "grand conspiracy" investigation in August 2025 to target Obama-era officials, and that its scope has since expanded to examine allegations that Biden officials also conspired to unlawfully prosecute Trump.
Two exits already. Fox News says Essayli is the latest prosecutor put in charge after two others resigned. Jason Reding Quiñones, the U.S. attorney for the Southern District of Florida, left abruptly a few weeks ago, two months after taking over from Joe diGenova. Fox News says diGenova, picked by Attorney General Todd Blanche to supervise the investigation, resigned in September, five months after being tapped, amid frustration in the White House and Justice Department over the lack of criminal charges. Fox News also says its earlier reporting found diGenova had effectively been sidelined before he left. One oddity: the Fox News story names both Pam Bondi and Todd Blanche as attorney general at different points. We could not reconcile that and report it as Fox News wrote it.
The authority question. According to Fox News, in October U.S. District Judge J. Michael Seabright ruled that Essayli was unlawfully serving as a "de facto" U.S. attorney, finding the Justice Department had circumvented limits on temporary appointments by letting him keep exercising the powers of the office without Senate confirmation. The ruling disqualified him from supervising two criminal prosecutions. Fox News says that on Monday the judge rejected the department's request to pause that ruling while it appeals. Fox News says the ruling does not automatically invalidate the Florida assignment but raises questions about his authority in Los Angeles.
Criticism. Fox News says House Democrats led by Rep. Dave Min of California have demanded an ethics probe over what they call "politically-motivated investigations," and that Democrats and defense attorneys question whether Essayli can be impartial because of his close ties to Trump. Defense lawyer H. Dean Steward, who successfully challenged Essayli's authority, accused the administration of violating federal law "in an effort to install minions as chief federal prosecutors," Fox News reports. Fox News says it asked the U.S. Attorney's Office for comment and had not received a response.
What we could not check. The assignment rests on anonymous sources. We did not read the Seabright ruling or any Justice Department statement.