Justice Alito Says Free Speech, Religious Liberty and Racial Equality Must Be Preserved 'No Matter What the Atmosphere Is,' Fox News Reports
At a Federalist Society fireside chat with Mollie Hemingway, the justice named three principles he says the country must hold and said the midterm sweep did not change his plans to stay on the Court.
Justice Samuel Alito used a public conversation recently to name the three things he says Americans cannot give up, Fox News reports. We read Fox's full text, not a recording of the event.
The setting. Fox says Alito spoke with Federalist editor-in-chief Mollie Hemingway at a fireside chat that followed the Antonin Scalia Memorial Dinner at the 2026 National Lawyers Convention in Washington. He said, "I'm not saying we're entering the dark age, but these are things that we have to preserve no matter what the atmosphere is in the country or the world at the time."
Free speech. Alito said there can be no democratic self-fulfillment without robust free speech, "even speech that is hurtful to some of the people who hear what is being said."
Religious liberty. He said the Court has put religious liberty "on a sounder footing than it was on 20, 25 years ago," and called it central to human dignity in a country with followers of nearly every faith. Fox notes the justices have at least two major religious freedom cases this term, St. Mary Catholic Parish v. Roy and Grand v. City of University Heights.
Racial equality. Alito called it "essential for our pluralistic society" and pointed to Martin Luther King Jr.'s hope that children would be judged by the content of their character. Fox says the Court agreed in October to hear a challenge from parents of Asian American students to a Maryland school district's admissions policy. Alito named the 2023 Students for Fair Admissions ruling as one of the most consequential in recent decades.
Retirement. Fox says Alito told Bloomberg after the midterms that the Democratic sweep did not change his plans. He is 76 and has served since 2006. He noted that he has risen to 42nd on the list of all-time service by justices.
The political backdrop. Fox frames the remarks against the midterm losses, saying Republicans lost 42 House seats and eight Senate seats with the Alaska Senate race still uncalled, and against calls from incoming Democrats for investigations of the administration.
Why it matters here. Retirement talk shapes how Republicans think about the Senate and the Court, and Alito's answer is on the record. The principles he named are a statement of his judicial outlook, not a ruling.
What we could not check. The seat counts are Fox's. We did not hear the full conversation or review the pending cases.